Charles Piele no.9 Targeted Discrimination and Human Right Violator in Lu's case. Charles Piele is another staff members covered up Lu's case. He was another Defendant left his position after the lawsuit. On late November 2012, Yung-Kai Lu filed a internal appeal to him with sufficient evidence that Lori McDonald led 9 faculty and staff members to manufacture his false medical and criminal reports. Yung-Kai Lu also proved that the work performance letter was wrong and the school of music failed to promote his position under Donn Schaefer's promise. Charles Piele failed to correct all faculty members and staff members' wrongdoings to Lu and immediately close the case without any explanations. Because Charles Piele failed to correct all the mistakes after reviewing Lu's proves, Lu moved on his complaint to the U.S. Federal Courts. The court confirmed Yung-Kai Lu&